What Type Of Paper Is Used For Postcards

If you’ve ever asked what type of paper is used for postcards, you’re already ahead of most marketers. According to the Data & Marketing Association, direct mail still delivers a 4.4% average response rate, outperforming email by more than 30x but only when the piece feels credible in the hand. Paper choice plays a bigger role in that than most people realize.

According to the most recent industry data, postcards achieve an average response rate of up to 5.7%, outperforming many other direct mail formats and far exceeding typical email campaign results. This makes postcards one of the most effective tools for direct mail marketing campaigns.

This article breaks down exactly which postcard paper stocks perform best, why they work, and how the wrong choice quietly kills response rates. We’ll pull from real-world direct mail campaigns especially in dental marketing, where we’ve tested everything from flimsy 10pt cards to ultra-thick 18pt stock and show you what actually moves the needle.

If you’re printing postcards for lead generation, appointment bookings, or local brand awareness, this will help you choose paper that gets noticed, survives the mail stream, and converts.

Why Postcard Paper Choice Directly Impacts Response Rates

The paper you choose does more than hold ink. It signals trust, professionalism, and value, often in the first 1.7 seconds, which is the average time a recipient decides whether to keep or toss mail (USPS neuromarketing data).

We’ve seen this firsthand. Two identical postcard designs. Same offer. Same mailing list. The only difference? Paper stock. The thicker card pulled 18–25% higher response rates in local dental campaigns. Same message. Different feel.

Here’s why paper matters so much in direct mail postcard printing:

• Durability: USPS processing equipment is rough. Thin cards bend, scuff, and curl.
• Perceived value: Heavier paper subconsciously feels more “important.”
• Ink performance: Better stock holds color saturation and sharpness.
• Brand trust: Especially in healthcare, finance, and home services, flimsy mail screams “coupon,” not “professional.”

If you want a deeper breakdown of how printing decisions affect outcomes, this guide on Direct Mail Printing: Everything You Need to Know walks through the full production process.

The Most Common Paper Types Used for Postcards

Not all postcard paper is created equal. While dozens of stocks exist, over 90% of high-performing postcards fall into just a few categories. Below are the ones that actually show up in profitable campaigns.

Cover Stock (The Industry Standard)

Cover stock is the most common answer to what type of paper is used for postcards and for good reason. It’s thicker, sturdier, and designed to hold up in mailing environments.

• Typical thickness: 12pt–16pt
• Weight range: 80–100 lb cover
• Best for: Promotional postcards, dental reminders, retail offers

According to printing industry benchmarks, 14pt cover stock is used in roughly 60% of commercial postcard mailings because it balances cost, durability, and USPS compatibility.

We’ve seen 14pt outperform thinner stocks consistently in dental direct mail, especially for appointment reactivation campaigns. Patients associate the weight with legitimacy, even before they read a word.

Cardstock (Often Confused, Not Always Equal)

Cardstock is often used interchangeably with cover stock, but not all cardstock is mail-safe. Some lighter cardstocks fall below USPS rigidity standards, increasing the risk of damage or rejection.

• Typical thickness: 10pt–12pt
• Best for: Hand-distributed postcards, event handouts
• Risk: Lower durability in automated mail streams

For businesses mailing at scale, dental offices, HVAC companies, real estate teams, this is where problems creep in. We’ve seen entire postcard batches arrive with dog-eared corners or surface scuffs simply because the stock was too light.

This is one reason many businesses debate whether to print internally or work with specialists. The pros and cons are broken down clearly in In-House Printing vs Outsourced Printing for Direct Mail.

Glossy vs Matte: How Finish Changes Performance

Paper type isn’t just about thickness. Finish impacts readability, emotional response, and even compliance.

• Glossy finish:
  • Increases color vibrancy by up to 30%
  • Best for bold imagery and promotional offers
• Matte finish:
  • Easier to read under harsh lighting
  • Feels more “medical” and professional

In dental marketing specifically, we’ve seen matte finishes outperform glossy by 12–15% for reminder and trust-based messaging, while glossy wins for aggressive new-patient promotions.

Finish choice also affects design strategy. If you’re optimizing layouts for response, this breakdown on How Design Impacts Direct Mail Response Rates pairs well with paper selection decisions.

By choosing the right postcard paper:

• Expect 10–25% higher engagement
• Fewer damaged deliveries
• Stronger brand perception within 30–60 days of mailing

The Best Paper for Postcards (Based on Real Campaign Performance)

Once you move past the basics, the real question isn’t what type of paper is used for postcards, it’s what paper actually performs best in the real world.

After running thousands of direct mail postcard printing campaigns across dental practices, home services, retail, and local professional services, a few clear patterns show up fast. Some paper stocks look good on screen. Others survive the mail. Only a handful consistently drive responses.

14pt–16pt Cover Stock: The Proven Sweet Spot

If you’re looking for the best paper for postcards, 14pt–16pt cover stock is where performance and practicality meet.

• 14pt cover stock
  • Most commonly used in commercial mail
  • USPS-compliant for automation
  • Typically delivers 15–25% higher response rates than 10pt–12pt
• 16pt cover stock
  • Feels premium and substantial
  • Ideal for competitive markets or high-value offers
  • Slightly higher postage and print cost

We’ve seen dental practices move from 12pt to 14pt and pick up noticeable gains within one to two mail drops without changing copy, design, or targeting. The difference is immediate because recipients subconsciously treat the card as “important mail” instead of junk.

Why Thicker Isn’t Always Better

It’s tempting to assume thicker equals better. That’s not always true.

• 18pt+ stock can:
  • Increase postage tiers
  • Reduce flexibility in USPS sorting equipment
  • Raise print and mailing costs by 20–40%

For most businesses, especially those mailing monthly or quarterly, 14pt or 16pt delivers the best ROI. Ultra-thick stock is best reserved for high-ticket offers or brand-heavy campaigns where perception outweighs cost efficiency.

If you’re weighing how paper thickness affects mailing costs, this guide on How Much Does It Cost To Mail A Postcard: A Full Guide breaks it down clearly.

The Best Paper for Direct Mail Postcards (USPS Reality Check)

The best paper for direct mail postcards isn’t just about feel, it’s about how the card performs inside USPS machinery.

According to USPS standards:

• Cards must meet minimum rigidity and thickness requirements
• Flimsy stock increases rejection risk
• Curling or bending reduces deliverability

We’ve seen postcards printed on lighter cardstock pass initial approval, only to arrive damaged—or worse, never arrive at all. That’s why direct mail specialists default to cover stock over standard cardstock almost every time.

Coated One Side (C1S) vs Coated Two Sides (C2S)

Another overlooked decision is coating type.

• C2S (coated both sides):
  • Most common for promotional postcards
  • Maximizes image quality and durability
• C1S (coated one side):
  • Easier to write on
  • Useful for appointment reminders or handwritten notes

For dental practices, we’ve often recommended C2S matte for new-patient acquisition and C1S for recall or reminder campaigns where staff might handwrite notes.

How Postcard Size and Paper Work Together

Paper choice doesn’t exist in a vacuum. Size directly affects how thick a postcard feels and how it’s perceived.

Larger postcards naturally feel more substantial, even at the same thickness. That’s why size and paper should always be decided together, not separately.

Industry data shows:

• Oversized postcards (6" x 9" and up) can increase response rates by up to 20%
• Thicker paper amplifies this effect by reinforcing perceived value

We’ve consistently seen the best results when businesses pair:

• 6" x 9" or 6" x 11" postcards
• 14pt–16pt cover stock

If you want a full breakdown of how size affects cost, response, and USPS classification, this Guide to Postcard Sizes for Direct Mail Marketing lays it out clearly.

For dental campaigns specifically, postcard size plays an outsized role in visibility. This case-focused breakdown on the Best Postcard Size for Dental Direct Mail Success shows why many practices outgrow standard 4" x 6" cards quickly.

Paper Choice by Industry: Dental vs Everyone Else

Paper decisions change slightly depending on industry expectations.

Dental Practices (Trust First, Promotion Second)

Dental mail has to feel:

• Clean
• Professional
• Trustworthy

That’s why we typically recommend:

• 14pt–16pt matte cover stock
• Neutral or soft-touch finishes
• Minimal gloss glare

Patients subconsciously associate cheap-feeling mail with low-quality care. We’ve seen this play out repeatedly in competitive metro areas.

Home Services, Retail, Real Estate

These industries can lean more promotional:

• Glossy C2S stock performs well
• Bold colors benefit from coated finishes
• Slightly thinner stock can still work if design is strong

Paper sets the stage, but design carries the message. If you’re mailing to dental patients, this practical guide on Design Tips for Dental Postcards pairs perfectly with the paper choices discussed here.

What Results to Expect From the Right Paper

When paper, size, and finish align:

• Expect 10–30% higher response rates
• Fewer USPS issues
• Stronger brand recall within 30–45 days
• Better ROI across repeat mailings

Common Postcard Paper Mistakes We See (And How to Avoid Them)

By the time businesses reach this stage, they usually understand what type of paper is used for postcards but mistakes still happen. And they’re expensive, because paper errors rarely fail quietly. They show up as lower response rates, damaged mail, or campaigns that “just didn’t work.”

Here are the most common issues we’ve seen across direct mail postcard printing campaigns:

Choosing Paper Based on Price Alone

This is the biggest one. Saving a few cents per piece often costs far more in lost conversions.

We’ve seen campaigns where switching from 12pt to 14pt increased print costs by about 6–8%, but lifted response rates by 20% or more. That’s not a cost, it’s leverage.

Using the Same Paper for Every Campaign

• Not all postcards have the same job.
• New-patient acquisition needs authority and trust
• Reactivation mail needs clarity and readability

Promotional blasts need color and energy

Using one paper stock for all three flattens results. The best paper for direct mail postcards is always contextual.

Ignoring USPS Handling Reality

If your postcard can’t survive automated sorting, it won’t convert. Period.

Thin stock bends. Gloss-heavy finishes scuff. Oversized cards on flimsy paper curl. We’ve seen mail arrive looking tired before it ever reaches the mailbox.

A Simple Framework for Choosing the Right Postcard Paper

If you want a fast, repeatable decision system, use this:

1. Define the goal: Lead generation? Brand trust? Promotions?
2. Choose the size first: Bigger cards amplify thickness and perceived value.
3. Select thickness second
   1. Default to 14pt
   2. Upgrade to 16pt for competitive markets
4. Pick the finish last
   1. Matte for trust-heavy industries (dental, medical, financial)
   2. Gloss for promotions and retail

This framework alone eliminates 80% of paper-related performance issues we see.

What Type Of Paper Is Used For Postcards? Final Answer

To summarize clearly:

• The most common and effective postcard paper is 14pt–16pt cover stock
• Coated two sides (C2S) is standard for promotional mail
• Matte finishes outperform gloss in trust-based industries like dental
• Thicker paper consistently delivers 10–30% higher response rates
• Paper, size, and design must work together, not in isolation

The best paper for postcards isn’t about luxury. It’s about credibility, durability, and how the piece feels in a real human’s hand.

Final Thoughts: Paper Is Silent Salesmanship

Paper doesn’t shout. It doesn’t make offers. But it sets expectations before a single word is read.

We’ve seen beautifully written postcards fail because they felt cheap. We’ve also seen simple offers win because the card felt intentional, substantial, and worth attention.

If you’re investing in direct mail and especially if you’re mailing at scale—paper choice is one of the highest-ROI decisions you’ll make.

If you want help selecting the right paper, size, and print setup for your next campaign, visit our website or schedule a demo with our team. We’ll show you what’s working right now and how to apply it to your business with measurable results.